Marital dispute erupts when man insists on splitting inheritance evenly among children to avoid favoritism, but wife demands that they prioritize one child over the others

Advertisement
  • 01
    3454 100 "My wife hasn't spoken to me since our last discussion about this. She thinks I'm being unfair by not considering individual circumstances. But I keep thinking about how I'd feel as one of the kids getting less —– like my parents valued me less than my siblings." -
  • 02
    r/AITAH u/Tanvir5012 • 22h AITA for wanting to split inheritance money equally between my kids when my wife wants to prioritize one?
  • 03
    Recently came into some money and facing a difficult situation with my wife about how to distribute it between our three children. I believe the fairest approach is to split it equally three ways. My wife, however, wants to give a larger portion to one of our kids.
  • 04
    The money is enough to make a meaningful difference in each child's life if split evenly. While I understand the instinct to give more help to a child who may need it, I worry about creating resentment and damaging sibling relationships. An equal split feels like the clearest way to show we value all our children the same.
  • 05
    My wife hasn't spoken to me since our last discussion about this. She thinks I'm being unfair by not considering individual circumstances. But I keep thinking about how I'd feel as one of the kids getting less like my parents valued me less than my - sibling.
  • 06
    The money is technically mine to distribute, but I want to handle this in a way that keeps peace in the family. Still, my gut says equal shares is right. AITA for insisting on an equal split rather than going along with my wife's wish to give more to one child? 4,845 2,409 D
  • 07
    Used Mark_7911 • 22h INFO: What is your wife's reasoning for wanting to give one child a larger share? ... Reply 5.2k
  • 08
    Another_Russian_Spy⚫ 20h "While I understand the instinct to give more help to a child who may need it," I took this sentence to mean one kid was in a worse financial situation. But they don't explain why. 171
  • 09
    HumanStudenten • 17h I took it to mean they may be disabled or disadvantaged somehow and not able to work for themselves. More info needed. 61
  • 10
    illini02 • 8h Reddit is interesting, because people always jump to some kind of disability, whereas I just think of one kid as being financially irresponsible. 35
  • 11
    Kckc321 .7h It could legit be either. My brother is disabled but a large portion of our family doesn't "believe" in TBIs or autism and so would portray this situation as he's just a lazy pos who "refuses" to work.
  • 12
    Beth21286 ⚫ 21h I was assuming one child just makes less money than the others but you're right, without more info you can't really make a judgement. 265
  • 13
    mfatty2 • 20h This is why I almost feel like the wife might have a valid reason. Because OP omits any reasoning other than it would help the one more than the other(s) 158
  • 14
    Impressive-Maize-815 • 19h Especially since wife is now not speaking to OP. There is a reason she feels that strongly about this. 29 ↓
  • 15
    DaisyAylin 20h • NTA. Splitting the inheritance equally is the fairest approach and prevents resentment among your children. 152
  • 16
    No Excuse_6317.6h Nah, you're not the a h_le. Splitting it equally makes sense-nobody feels left out or less loved. Picking favorites with money? That's how family drama starts fr. Stay firm on this one. Reply 316
  • 17
    mustang19671967 • 22h The only reason to maybe make it different, is if one child Will Need help the rest of their life from a physical disability or A mental disability. Are you setting up a trust now Otherwise you can change your will At any time ... Reply 5.2k
  • 18
    Coop654321 • 22h Agreed. My younger sister for reasons beyond her control has never married, has no kids, will never own her own home & will have a limited retirement income. I've told my parents that they need to leave their paid-for home to her to do whatever she wants with in their will. She'll need that, I won't. Context here matters. 94
  • 19
    ExpiredPilot 22h . This was my thought if I ever won the lotto. The family would get a predetermined amount each, except for my cousin with nonverbal autism. His trust is gonna be bigger to help pay for lifelong disability care at the best facility money can get. ← û 76
  • 20
    ladydreaam 18h Honestly, I get that you want to be fair, but if your wife feels like one kid needs more help, that should be considered. However, I totally see where you're coming from, too. It's hard to avoid favoritism, and it could really mess with the kids' relationships in the future. Maybe there's a way to talk about it more openly, so everyone's needs are heard without it turning into a huge conflict. ← Reply 299
  • 21
    NTA. Existing-Solution590 • 22h Ask your wife if she's willing to sit the kids down and explain to them why one gets more than the others....my guess is if she actually had to face their reactions and feelings on one getting preferential treatment she wouldn't do it ... Reply 607
  • 22
    SummitJunkie7 • 22h Also, you don't know when this inheritance will happen or what each person's circumstances will be when it does. What if "needy" kid is quite successful by then while the other has fallen on hard times? ... 157

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article